It’s September. The leaves will soon be turning colors, the air will take on a new crispness, it’ll soon be time to plant tulip bulbs, and of course, college football season has begun. I’ll still watch soccer before football, but I haven’t completely lost interest in the NCAA. I have, however, lost faith in
the dipshits who manage the college football structure. No matter how many polls you take or how much tweaking the BCS ranking system undergoes, the system remains as lame as [insert politician here]’s last attempt at humor.
The only way to determine a real champion is on the field. But unlike most fans, I’m not going to call for a March Madness-like tournament. Football teams just can’t play enough games in one season to have a regular season and then a lengthy tournament. Instead I’m going to propose something radical, definitive, fair, and beautiful in its simplicity, and therefore a plan that the NCAA would never consider.
Do away with the bowl games altogether. Who cares about the result of the FlyByNight.com IPO Dutch Auction Bowl anyway? And do away with the current conference schedules. Tradition my ass. The Big Ten has eleven teams now. The ACC, SEC, Big 12 and most of the minor conferences look different today from the way they did just a handful of years ago. And my own beloved Southwest Conference doesn’t even exist anymore. Face it; tradition in major college sports lasts only as long as the current rights and broadcasting contract. Scrap all of it. And while we’re at it, repeal overtime. With the two-point conversion option, force the coach to make a real decision. Do you have the cojones to go for the win and risk the loss? No? Then settle for the tie, little man.
Instead of all that traditional crap, here’s what we need. Choose whatever ranking system you think is the fairest. They all suck, just pick one because we’ll only use it this once and then it’s gone forever. Rank the teams from 1 to however the hell many there are. Then start splitting the teams into divisions by these rankings. In other words, the top 15 ranked teams are Division 1, the next 15 are Division 2, and so on. Each team will play the other 14 teams in their division, seven games at home, seven away. That way we won’t have Oklahoma playing the first half of its schedule against the stepsisters of the poor. The entire season will be played against similarly ranked opponents, guaranteeing exciting games every Saturday.
Just as soccer leagues do, award the game winner three points in the standings, the loser nothing. When teams tie, they each get a point. At the end of the 14 weeks, the team at the top of the division standings is a real champion, decided on the field over the course of the entire season. And the big kicker?
At the end of the season, the bottom two teams in each division get relegated to the next lower division, replaced by the two best teams in that division. There’s a reward for a great season—promotion into a higher division, and a penalty for a bad season—relegation to a lower league. Within a few seasons, the possible inequities from the initial rankings will be worked out by the play of the teams themselves.
I know it’ll never happen, but it would be sweet.